Spring 1998

Newsletter from the Honourable Sharon Carstairs, Senator For Manitoba
Number 6

Introduction
Government Bills
Update - Section 43
Gathering Strength - Canada's Aboriginal Action Plan
How a bill becomes a law - The Senate's Role
Update - Prairie Action Foundation
International Summit of Sexually Exploited Youth

Introduction

Dear Readers,

Spring is once again upon us and at this time I would like to update you about my activities over the winter.

It has been seven months now since I accepted the position of Deputy Leader of the Government in the Senate. The months have been filled with interesting challenges and new responsibilities. As always, I have met them head on.

In my new position, I am responsible for the day to day management of legislation in the Senate. This requires that I be in the Senate Chamber at all times while the Senate is sitting. The unfortunate side of this is that I have not spent as much time in Winnipeg as I would have liked. However, this Spring I will be spending as many week-ends in Manitoba as possible, as well as most of the summer months.

This fall has seen the adoption of some historic legislation, including Bill C-22, the Land Mines Act. A fellow Manitoban, the Honourable Lloyd Axworthy, Minister of Foreign Affairs, was the major proponent of the Bill. Following the passage of this legislation, I was honoured to attend the poignant Treaty Signing Conference and Mine Action Forum here in Ottawa.

More recently, I was pleased to meet with a delegation from the Cuban government to discuss the role of the Senate in the Canadian Parliament. In particular, I spoke about my role as Deputy Leader in the Senate. By sharing this information with Cuba, Canada is making an effort to encourage the peaceful evolution of Cuban society. The aim is full respect for human rights, with genuinely representative institutions and an open economy.

On March 23, 1998 I had the pleasure to speak at the Family and Children’s Services of Guelph Wellington County, Annual General Meeting on the Repeal of Section 43 of the Criminal Code of Canada.

I hope that you find this newsletter informative.

Enjoy your spring! 


Selected Government Bills Currently Before the Senate

Bill C-4, The Canadian Wheat Board Act, is currently before the Standing Senate Committee on Agriculture and Forestry. From March 24th to April 2nd, this Committee traveled through the West holding hearings on the subject of the bill. Further hearings will be scheduled in Ottawa for early April.

Bill C-6, The Mackenzie Valley Resource Management Act, was referred to the Standing Senate Committee on Aboriginal Peoples on March 26, 1998.

Bill C-9, The Ports Bill, was referred to the Senate Committee, Transport and Communications. Among other initiatives this legislation seeks to establish Canada Port Authorities which will manage major self sufficient Canadian ports. This committee will hold extensive hearings in April.

Bill C-18, The Customs Act, is currently before the Standing Senate Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs. This bill seeks to give custom officers the power to detain or arrest individuals that are suspected of committing offences which fall under the Criminal Code, such as impaired driving or child abduction

 


UPDATE ON THE REPEAL OF SECTION 43

On March 11, 1998 Mr. Tony Ianno, MP for Trinity-Spadina, introduced Bill C-368, An Act to amend the Criminal Code and the Department of Health Act (security of the child). This bill is identical to S-14. Which was the bill I introduced in the Senate that died on the Order Paper at the call of the 1997 federal election.

The Canadian Foundation for Children, Youth and the Law intends to commence an application in 1998, in the Ontario Courts as a public interest litigant for a declaration that Section 43 of the Criminal Code is unconstitutional. The primary basis for the challenge is the legal argument that the defence infringes the child’s right to equal benefit and protection of the law under section 15 of the Charter, and the child’s right to security of the person under section 7 of the Charter. Reliance will also be placed upon Canada’s obligations under the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child.

 


Gathering Strength: Canada’s Aboriginal Action Plan

In response to the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples, the Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development unveiled, on January 7, 1998, Gathering Strength: Canada’s Aboriginal Action Plan. This action plan marks a turning point in relations between the federal government and Aboriginal Canadians. It calls for a new partnership in dealing with the negative legacies of the Aboriginal experience in Canada. Initiatives include:

  • $350 million will be invested over 4 years towards community based healing for victims of abuse at Indian Residential Schools.
  • Plans to work towards the development of effective and accountable Aboriginal governments and institutions.
  • Increasing Aboriginal governments financial self-reliance by developing additional sources of revenue.
  • Development of stronger and healthier Aboriginal communities, such as with the expansion of the Aboriginal Head Start program to children on reserves.
  • An examination of ways to confirm the contributions of the Metis people in Canada.

 


How a Bill Becomes Law: The Senate’s Role

The Canadian Constitution states that both the Senate and the House of Commons must each approve proposed legislation in order for it to become law. This process serves as a check and balance for our legislative system.

The Canadian law making process begins with a bill - a proposal to either create a new law or to change an existing law. A bill can be introduced in the House of Commons (C-bills) or the Senate (S-bills). The majority of public bills start in the House of Commons. Public bills are concerned with matters of public policy such as taxes and spending, health and other social programs. The majority of private bills are introduced in the Senate and are in response to a petition. These bills address the needs of a single person, company or institution. The only bills that cannot be initiated in the Senate are "money" bills. That is, bills which spend government money or impose a tax.

A bill goes through several formal stages in each house. These stages include a series of "readings" during which parliamentarians debate the bill. Prior to the third and final reading, each house also sends the bill to a committee where members examine the fine points of the legislation.

They listen to witnesses give their opinions on the bill, and then subject it to a clause-by-clause study based on the testimony. At this stage either house can do one of four things with a bill: pass it, amend it, delay it or defeat it.

Once both Houses pass a bill, it is presented for Royal Assent and becomes law. All Canadian laws are formally "enacted" by the Sovereign, or her representative the Governor General, "by and with the advice and consent" of the Senate and House of Commons. To become a law a bill must pass the Senate, the House of Commons and be given Royal Assent.

The Senate plays a key role in amending bills passed by the House of Commons. Senators have the expertise to put a bill under the microscope and examine it in detail, and the Senate timetable allows for longer periods of study.

The Senate can also delay a bill, or decide not to act on it at all. This means that without being formally defeated, the bill dies at the end of the session. To illustrate, in 1985 the Senate delayed a $19.3 billion borrowing bill until the Government showed how it intended to spend the funds. It passed the bill after the House of Commons approved the Government’s spending estimates.

And last, a bill can be defeated. Canada’s Constitution gives either House of Parliament the power to defeat proposed legislation sent to it by the other house. This is called the veto power. Though the Senate does not oppose the will of the Commons very often, Senators have rejected bills in the past. This occurs even less frequently in the House of Commons. If the House of Commons defeats a major piece of legislation, the Government usually resigns and an election is called. If a bill is defeated in the Senate, the Government can go back to the drawing board and submit a new bill.

Adapted from "The Senate Today" 


Update on the Prairie Action Foundation

The five year government commitment for federal funding of five Canadian Research Centres on Family Violence and Violence Against Women has now ended. However, plans for the long term survival of the Manitoba Centre are well under way. We have established a Prairie research centre on family violence and the Prairie Action Foundation to fund the centre. The goal of the Foundation is to raise the $5 million endowment fund required to fund the new Prairie Centre.

In the second week of February, the Foundation held its first meeting of the newly recruited Board. The acting officers were confirmed and the by-laws were ratified. A second meeting of the Board was held in March. With our charitable tax status in hand, we are currently getting ready for the official launch of our fundraising campaign in September, 1998.

Prairie Research Centre development activities in Alberta and Saskatchewan are ongoing. Steering councils for the regional Board of the new Centre have been established in both provinces. The Centre hopes to have at least one research project from each province linked to the Centre within the next two months! 


The International Summit of Sexually Exploited Youth, held March 12 - 17, 1998 in Victoria B.C., declared the following:

We declare that the term child or youth prostitute can no longer be used. These children and youth are sexually exploited and any language or reference to them must reflect this belief.

We declare that the commercial sexual exploitation of children and youth is a form of child abuse and slavery.

We declare that all children and youth have the right to be protected from all forms of abuse, exploitation and the threat of abuse, harm or exploitation.

We declare that the commercial exploitation of children and youth must no longer be financially profitable.

We declare that all children and youth have the right to know their rights.

We declare that the issue of child and youth sexual exploitation must be a global priority and nations must not only hold their neighbours accountable but also themselves.

We declare that governments are obliged to create laws which reflect the principle of zero tolerance of all forms of abuse and exploitation of children and youth.

Français | Home| Contact Us | Feedback |
Senator Carstairs | The Senate | Palliative Care | News/Events | FYI | Useful Links